Are Romeo and Juliet Really in Love?

Are Romeo and Juliet Really in Love?

Rather than being star-crossed lovers, Romeo and Juliet are just naive, impulsive teenagers. William Shakespeare’s “Romeo and Juliet” has long been considered one of the greatest examples of pure love. The play is just a horrible twist of fate set up by Shakespeare. His nuanced critique of the lovers’ actions is essentially a veiled criticism. Shakespeare demonstrates that Romeo and Juliet’s sad deaths are the product of Romeo and Juliet’s actions and decisions rather than a bad planetary alignment. The characters’ actions and words.

Get Your Custom Essay Written From Scratch
Are You Overwhelmed With Writing Assignments?
Give yourself a break and turn to our top writers. They’ll follow all the requirements to compose a premium-quality piece for you.
Order Now

To express the love that has no bounds, we often use the phrase “like Romeo and Juliet,” but a thorough reading of the play reveals that the lovers’ sentiments were more nuanced. Romeo and Juliet’s love for one another, at least in the beginning, appear to be immature. Romeo claims to be in love with Rosaline at the beginning of the play. It shows that his sentiments toward both women are shallow since he abandons Rosaline before he even talks with Juliet. On the other hand, Juliet appears to be motivated by a desire to oppose her family. She doesn’t like her parent’s choice of a spouse and kisses Romeo instead of Paris after just fourteen lines of speech with him at the party where they were scheduled to meet.

When Romeo visits Juliet again, she is intent on getting married. The fact that she would no longer be a Capulet is one of the reasons why marriage appeals to Juliet. Using tassel-gentle as a metaphor for Romeo, she implies that she feels she can control him. Romeo’s attraction to Juliet appears to be motivated at least in part by Juliet’s desire for a husband who will not be able to govern her like her parents are.

Even though Romeo’s actions were guided by love, his death resulted from his bad decisions and lack of foresight. Romeo’s lack of common sense guides his behavior even before he meets Juliet. He’s unhappy with Rosaline at the start of the play. Because she plans to become a nun, she must maintain her virginity. Ever the theatrical one, Romeo offers his take on the situation: “She hath pledged love, and in that vow/ Do I live dead, that live to tell it now.” Rather than referring to Juliet, Romeo’s remark refers to a different one of his long-term flings. In the same way, Romeo was prepared to die for Juliet because it was the romantic thing to do. This indicates how Romeo had been “star-crossed” before. To use current slang, a man who is theatrical in love is referred to as a “Romeo.”

According to more mature characters, Romeo and Juliet’s desire for one another stems from sexual dissatisfaction rather than enduring love. It is like “a great natural that runs lolling up and down to hide his jewel in the hole,” Mercutio tells Romeo. Mercutio constantly challenges Romeo’s attempts to show the intensity of his love. Mercutio tells Romeo, “O that she was / An open-arse, thou a proper pear!” as Romeo returns to the Capulets’ house to see Juliet again. She reminds out that Juliet’s love has a sexual component to it. “For a hand and a foot and a body, if they are not to be spoken about, still they are beyond compare,” the nurse says as she returns after her first meeting with Romeo. According to the nurse, Juliet will be happy with Paris since he is more attractive than Romeo. “An eagle, madam / Hath not so green, so quick, so fair an eye / As Paris hath.”

However, Romeo and Juliet’s language demonstrates their passion evolving into true love, even though they may have first fallen in love for a mixture of convenience and lust. Romeo makes Benvolio and Mercutio chuckle in the opening scenes with his love clichés. After meeting Juliet, his clichés begin to fade, and he learns to express his emotions in new and creative ways. Romeo and Juliet develop a common language while they are together. They write a sonnet together in the sacred language of pilgrimage at their first meeting. They begin to define their feelings in astrological terms.

A couple in a committed relationship tends to employ less rhyme, making their language sound less contrived. The couple’s vocabulary has changed as they have matured together. Romeo and Juliet are ready to have their first serious conversation about something other than their failed love in their penultimate scene before they part ways for good. Tragically, no one ever gets to witness if Romeo and Juliet’s passion blossoms into a lasting partnership.

The Fake Love of Romeo and Juliet

Romeo and Juliet aren’t in love because they’re both looking for a way to forget their problems. He still loves Rosaline and is working on getting over her, so Romeo isn’t madly in love with Juliet. Romeo was worried about Rosaline’s unrequited love just minutes before they met Juliet. Romeo was only there to see Rosaline, which was the only reason he went to the Capulets’ celebration. The name Rosaline appeared on the guest list when Romeo’s servant approached him to read it before the party, and that’s what spurred him on to sneak into the party anyhow.

During Act 1, scene 3, Romeo declares, “I’ll go along…to enjoy the grandeur of my own”. Despite Benvolio’s plea that he should look at other women to move on from her, Rosaline was the only reason Romeo went to the ball. In the first place, Rosaline’s refusal to return Romeo’s love was the source of Romeo’s heartbreak. “she will not be struck by cupid’s arrow…from love’s weak, infantile bow, she lives unharmed”. Because he recognizes Rosaline’s name on the guest list, Romeo decides to go to the ball to cheer himself up. Romeo says to Juliet after slipping into the celebration, “Did my heart love till now? Forsake your sense of sight, for I had never seen pure beauty before.

Rosaline was the most beautiful girl in Romeo’s eyes just a few days before this encounter, and he claims he has never seen someone as gorgeous as Juliet. The only thing that makes her impoverished is that her beauty dies with her. Romeo predicts that beauty will die at the same time as Rosaline. Because of this, it’s hard to tell which of the two women is the prettiest or which one Romeo has feelings for. Romeo is torn between loving Rosaline and hating her since she is both a Capulet and stunning.

Eventually, in the novel, Romeo says something that makes it plain that he is only with Juliet because she would return his love, unlike Rosaline: “Her I love now Doth grace for Grace allow and love for love allow. It was not the case with the other. One of the reasons Romeo loves Juliet is because she reciprocates his feelings, unlike Rosaline. It’s clear that Romeo is not infatuated with Juliet since she reciprocates his feelings for him, unlike Rosaline, and he quickly forgets her in the presence of Juliet’s Beauty.

Juliet, on the other hand, is uninterested in Romeo. She is attempting to escape a marriage to Paris by doing this. Because she didn’t want to marry Paris, Juliet’s sentiments toward Romeo were impacted by her refusal to marry him. In previous moments, Juliet consistently rejected her mother’s pleas to get interested in Paris.

Juliet and Romeo’s romance is based solely on mutual attraction. It’s hard to tell what their short-lived passion was made of. On the one hand, Romeo is a young man noted for his propensity for falling in love. Mercutio tells Romeo, “You’re a lover.'” in a chat. To soar above a common limit, borrow the wings of Cupid. Romeo, according to Mercutio, is a frequent lover who is capable of falling in love with a new woman in the same way he has in the past. Because Romeo has fallen in love many times, this fresh act of love is distinct from the others.

It was Juliet’s first romance, even though she was only 13 years old. He tells Paris in Act 1, scene 2: “My child is still a stranger in the world.” She hasn’t seen the world alter in 14 years. He’s telling Paris that Juliet doesn’t know what it’s like to live in the real world because she’s never had a romance or even left her parents’ house. This phrase might be used as evidence when considering Juliet’s assertion that she is in love with Romeo despite never having been in love before. If you haven’t been in a romantic relationship, how can you know what love feels like? Romeo and Juliet have no concept of what love is.

When it comes to Romeo’s suicide, it’s clear that he did it only because he couldn’t bear to be apart from the two ladies he had found true love with. To avoid the pain of Juliet’s death and Rosaline’s unrequited love, Romeo chooses to kill himself rather than live to honor Juliet, as mentioned in the statement. When the author of this article attacks Romeo’s false love, she points out that Romeo’s love is artificial since he only complements Juliet on her appearance. What gives me the right to rage at Romeo’s phony lovemaking?”

There is fake love between Romeo and Juliet due to the constant discourse about Juliet’s physical beauty, or other attractions can be forgiven even by Romeo. This line makes clear that Romeo can’t stop gushing about Juliet’s Beauty. That’s not love, you scumbag! That Romeo and Juliet were not in love is supported by this essay’s claim that Romeo’s words didn’t represent true love, but rather that he committed suicide to save Rosaline’s heartache and Juliet’s death and that Romeo was attracted to Juliet’s appearance.