What is Chillingworth Most Serious Sin?
Chillingworth most serious sin: He seeks revenge and deliberately, methodically ,destroys Arthur. Chillingworth’s shock quickly turns when he sees his wife on the scaffold holding a baby from another man.
Chillingworth is considered the worst sinner for blasphemy against Holy Spirit, an unforgivable sin. Three winners emerged from a Puritan town: Reverend Arthur Dimmesdale (Prynne) and Hester Pryne (Prynne). They all defied Puritan God and faced their fates. Hester and Dimmesdale were both guilty of similar sins, but Chillingworth’s was quite different. Hester’s sin was adultery. She had cheated upon her husband, Chillingworth. Dimmesdale’s sin was also sexual immorality. He knew he had a relationship with Hester, a married lady. Their sins are generally more manageable because they were consensual and did no harm.
Dimmesdale also committed sins against God. While promoting the dangers and lies of lying, Dimmesdale hid and lied through omission. His sin of hypocrisy did no harm to others but created distrust in his presence. Chillingworth continues to abuse and sin, despite knowing that murder and abuse are big sins. He could not be ignorant of sin because he was raised in Puritan towns and was married to a reverend. He must have known that murder and abuse were morally and religiously unacceptable, but he continues to do them. This is blasphemy against God and the Holy Spirit. God will punish this blasphemy, and Chillingworth will live in eternal sin. This is a stark illustration of the many sins committed by Chillingworth.
Roger Chillingworth is not like Dimmesdale and Hester. He is a flat character. He is a flawed character who transforms from a scholar to an obsessive friend. However, he is more like a symbol serving the devil’s will. We only see him in situations that involve his obsession for vengeance once he arrives in Boston. This is where we learn a lot about him. The Scarlet Letter reveals Chillingworth’s sins throughout. Hawthorne wanted Chillingworth to be the worst sinner because he used his herbs to keep Dimmesdale alive. He used black medicine and extended Dimmesdale’s torture. When Dimmesdale stopped using the herbs, he died.
With Chillingworth’s initial appearance, Hawthorne starts to build this symbol of evil revenge (“. . . Dropping down from the sky or starting from the nether Earth, it is said. . .”) In the novel, he is associated with wildness (the Indians), deformity, and mysterious power. His appearance is horrible after he has been held captive for over a year by the Indians. This is partly due to his bizarre mix of “civilized” and “savage” clothing.
Even when he’s dressed better, Chillingworth is still not very attractive. He is petite, thin, and slightly deformed, with one shoulder higher than another. He is “not old enough” but has wrinkles on his face and looks “well-stricken in years.” However, he has a calm, intelligent look. His eyes are dimmed and bleared because he spent so many hours studying under lamplight.
Roger Chillingworth is portrayed in the first scaffold scene. His wife, accused of adultery, arrives in Massachusetts Bay Colony. The reader feels somewhat sorry for him. He has a few options at that point. He chooses to take revenge. Chapter 9 describes his rude awakening. Hawthorne refers to him as “an elderly man who had traveled a lot and was just coming out of the wilderness.” After being separated from his wife, what should have been a loving and warm homecoming has turned into something terrible.
Chillingworth is not Puritan. He was held captive by the Indians for “up to a year” and did not consider them heathens or infidels. He also did not seek conversion like the Puritans. He studied the Indians’ knowledge of herbs and medicinal to learn. He has lived his entire life as a scholar alone, avoiding contact with other men when necessary to seek knowledge from the wider world. Later, he studies herbs and medicines to link his work with the “black medicine”, which helps him to keep his victim alive.
Hawthorne elaborates on this “other worldly” involvement, whether it is fateful or predetermined by a higher power. He describes Dimmesdale’s arrival as just in time to “help”. The Puritans believed that Providence or God was at work in all events. Hawthorne discredits the Puritans’ belief by mentioning Chillingworth’s arrival. He states: “Individuals with wiser faith, indeed,” and he adds, “Individuals who knew that Heaven promotes it purposes without aiming to the stage-effect or miraculous interposition, were inclined see a providential touch in Roger Chillingworth’s opportune appearance.”
Chillingworth arrives at the colony to learn about Hester’s condition. He leaves Hester alone for nearly seven years as he pursues Dimmesdale blindly. However, he does see the role he played in her demise. He realized that his marriage to her was not following “the laws of nature” because he had married her young and beautiful and then shut himself off with his books. He couldn’t believe she could marry a man who had been “misshapen from my birth hour”, despite being so beautiful. He believed that his intellect and beauty would make her forget his imperfections. Now he realizes that the scarlet letter was at the end of their journey from the moment they met.
Dimmesdale is attracted to Dimmesdale’s love for learning and intellectual pursuit. Men of learning were scarce in the New World. Hawthorne states that “there was a fascination in the minister in the company man of science; in whom he recognized intellectual cultivation of no moderate depth and scope; along with a range of ideas and freedom that he would not have vainly searched for among the members his profession.” This mutual love for wisdom drew the men together and will facilitate Chillingworth’s plans.
Hawthorne created Chillingworth as the “man of science”, a man who is pure intellect and reason without concern for feelings. Notice the “chilliness” in his name. Chapter 9 describes Chillingworth’s lack of scientific peers in the New World. “Skillful men of the medical or chirurgical profession were rare in the colony.” Because they are so involved in the human body science, these men of science have lost their spiritual perspective of humanity. Chillingworth is a shining example of this group. He lives in a world full of learning and scholarly pursuits. He was married to Hester, an attractive young woman. He kept his distance from her and pursued his scholarly pursuits alone.
Chillingworth decides that he will pursue Hester’s lover to exact revenge and uses scientists’ science-based techniques and motives to do so. He pokes and prods while Dimmesdale moves in. He believes that the soul is corrupted when the body becomes corrupt. “Wherever there’s a heart, and an intelligence, diseases of the body, are tinged by these peculiarities [the intellectual thoughts]. Chapter 9, “The Leech,” reveals Chillingworth’s motivations and techniques. He pursues his laboratory specimen as a scientist investigator. Hawthorne states, “Few secrets are possible to escape an investigator who has the opportunity and license to pursue such a quest and the skill to follow it up.”
Chillingworth starts his investigation as a scientist when he begins it. Hawthorne wrote, “He had started an investigation as he imagined. With the severe and equal integrity of a judge, desirous of truth, the question involved only the air-drawn figures and lines of a geometrical puzzle instead of human passions and wrongs inflicted upon itself.” Chillingworth’s pursuit is guided by the cold intellect of a nineteenth-century scientist. This makes Chillingworth a scoundrel, and Hawthorne considers him the greatest sinner. To see how Dimmesdale will respond, he violates Dimmesdale’s heart and soul. He lacks compassion for human beings. When Hester asks Chillingworth about Dimmesdale’s debt, Chillingworth replies that it was better if he died rather than suffer seven years of vengeance.
Roger Chillingworth is guilty of the gravest sin in “The Scarlet Letter.” Chillingworth sought revenge on the man who had betrayed him when he saw Hester on the scaffold in public humiliation. He spent the rest of his life seeking vicious revenge on Hester’s accomplice in adultery. Chillingworth was the pastor’s doctor after he suspected Dimmesdale of being his father. “For seven years, he served as Dimmesdale’s sponge, trying to heal his illness, but not fully. Chillingworth’s appearance changed a lot throughout this time. His appearance was more sinister than ever.
What is Chillingworth Most Serious Sin?